Navigate this Report
Back to Energy Storage Index
3. Business Case
6. Success Criteria
- A fuel cell is an electro-chemical device that combines hydrogen and oxygen to create water,with useful heat and electricity as it's byproducts.
- Fuel cells have the potential to replace the internal-combustion engine in vehicles and provide power in stationary and portable power applications because they are energy-efficient, clean, and fuel-flexible. Hydrogen or any hydrogen-rich fuel can be used by this emerging technology.
- Both fuel cells and batteries have two electrodes separated by an electrolyte. As with batteries the energy is converted to electrical form by chemical reactions but unlike battery cells the energy is derived from fuel which is dissipated in the discharge process and the fuel cell is "charged" by providing fresh fuel. In operation fuel cells run hot or very hot.
Wikipedia Glossary of fuel cell terms
- AFC - Alkaline Fuel Cells - Originally used in the space program, Performance is high, but so is cost.
- Ammonia Synthesis - The concept is to use energy generated by remote or offshore wind turbines to perform "solid-state ammonia synthesis" and transport that ammonia by land or sea to be used as a fuel. This obviates the need for distant wind farms to be expensively connected to the grid.
- DMTC - Direct Methanol Fuel Cell - use liquid methanol as a fuel and is being developed for small applications like laptop and cell phone batteries. Their main advantage is the ease of transport of methanol, an energy-dense yet reasonably stable liquid at all environmental conditions.
Efficiency is quite low for these cells, so they are targeted especially to portable applications, where energy and power density are more important than efficiency. A more efficient version of a direct fuel cell would play a key role in the theoretical use of methanol as a general energy transport medium, in the hypothesized methanol economy.
- MCFC -Molten Carbonate Fuel Cells - Operate like SOFC’s, except the electrolyte consists of liquid (molten) carbonate, which is a negative ion and an oxidizing agent. Because the electrolyte loses carbonate in the oxidation reaction, the carbonate must be replenished through some means. This is often performed by recirculating the carbon dioxide from the oxidation products into the cathode where it reacts with the incoming air and reforms carbonate.
High efficiency, resistant to contamination and can run on hydrocarbon fuels. They run at high temperatures and are being developed for utility applications. Because of high temperatures, durability is often an issue.
- PAFC - Phosphoric-Acid Fuel Cells - Comprise the largest segment of existing CHP products worldwide and can provide combined efficiencies close to 90% (35-50% electric + remainder as thermal) This type of fuel cell uses liquid phosphoric acid as an electrolyte. The electrodes are made of carbon paper coated with a finely-dispersed platinum catalyst, which make them expensive to manufacture. They are not affected by carbon monoxide impurities in the hydrogen stream. Phosphoric acid solidifies at a temperature of 40 °C, making startup difficult and restrains PAFCs to continuous operation.
First generation fuel cells. Quite mature, they have been used to power buses as well as stationary applications. Cost is high and efficiency is relatively low
At an operating range of 150 to 200 °C, the expelled water can be converted to steam for air and water heating. Phosphoric acid fuel cells have been used for stationary applications with a combined heat and power efficiency of about 80%, and they continue to dominate the on-site stationary fuel cell market.
PEM - Polymer Electrolyte Membrane - The Nafion membrane currently costs $565.92/m². In 2005 Ballard Power Systems announced that its fuel cells will use Solupor, a porous polyethylene film patented by DSM
- PEM - Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells - A type of fuel cell being developed for transport applications as well as for stationary fuel cell applications and portable fuel cell applications. Their distinguishing features include lower temperature/pressure ranges (50-100 degrees C) and a special polymer electrolyte membrane.
Often used in vehicle applications because of their fast response time. Cost is a factor as they use platinum catalysts.
- ACAL Energy Ltd, Runcorn, Cheshire, England - The world's leading developer of low cost Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) systems used to power fuel cells, powered by their proprietary platinum free cathode technology (FlowCath®)
- AFC Energy - Cranleigh, Surrey, England - An industrial fuel cell power company focused on large-scale stationary applications.
- Altergy Systems - Folsom, CA - Designs and manufactures proton exchange membrane fuel cell systems for telecommunications, data centers, and other mission-critical power applications in the United States and internationally. The company offers fuel cell backup systems and modules primarily for stationary power systems that provide primary or backup power for commercial or residential use; portable systems, such as generators or battery replacements; and motive applications, such as automobiles, forklifts, buses, and other vehicles. It also provides uninterruptible power supplies for information processing centers, acute medical care, homeland security, and other operations.
- Ballard Power (NASDAQ: BLDP) Burnaby, BC - Designs and manufactures clean energy hydrogen fuel cells. Their FCgen family of products delivers the Power to Change end user applications and business results.
- Backup Power - Enhances telecom network reliability with fuel cell powered backup power solutions.
- Residential Cogeneration - Enables consumers to gain energy independence in Japan using a fuel cell cogeneration system.
- Backup Power - Enhances telecom network reliability with fuel cell powered backup power solutions.
- Bloom Energy - Sunnyvale, CA - The Bloom Energy Server (the Bloom Box) is a solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) that can use a wide variety of inputs (including liquid or gaseous hydrocarbons produced from biological sources) to generate electricity on the site where it will be used. It can withstand temperatures of up to 1,800 °F (980 °C), that would cause many other fuel cells to break down or require maintenance. According to the company, a single cell (one 100 mm × 100 mm metal alloy plate between two ceramic layers) generates 25 watts. Bloom stated that two hundred servers have been deployed in California for corporations including eBay, Google, and Wal-Mart.
Bloom has been quite secretive about the inner workings of their Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC), which can generate electricity directly from natural gas and oxygen without combustion. There has been little to nothing in the way of technical publications or presentations at the many Fuel Cell Conferences.
The manufacturer says it will eventually market hand-held units powerful enough to run a single home for $3,000. The power will reportedly be cheaper than that purchased from standard power plants. Is the box as game-changing as its backers believe? Well, as 60 Minutes put it, it may just do to the power plant what the laptop did to the desktop because it doesn't require a grid.
The company has evolved their business model away from selling the units to a service that they call Electrons, which is more of a purchase power agreement. The customers commit to a ten-year deal, buying electricity at a fixed price while Bloom installs and maintains the units. They claim that they are looking for customers that currently spend $25,000 per month on electricity or more.
Bloom Energy posted $42 million of pro forma revenue and negative $61 million of pro forma operating income for Q1 2013, according to documents obtained by Fortune. Those figures are lower than Bloom results for both Q3 and Q4 2012. Bloom also reports negative $1.03 billion in retained earnings, compared to a negative $873 million mark through Q3 2012. To date, it has raised more than $1.1 billion in venture capital funding, including past investments from Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, New Enterprise Associates, Advanced Equities, DAG Ventures and Goldman Sachs.
But there are questions that remain unanswered. For one thing the Bloom Boxes, which the company calls energy servers, cost upwards of $800,000 for a 100kW system. While the company has not yet disclosed their operating costs, outside estimates project roughly $0.13 per kWh without incentives, which is higher than current market rate. The company claims a carbon footprint that is half of traditional power, but with no price on carbon, that could be a hard sell.
Another issue is product reliability. Bloom’s basic cell produces only 25 watts. That means that each 100kW module will contain 4000 cells requiring two interconnects each, always a trouble spot, especially in a device such as this that experiences big temperature swings.
- Ceres Power (LSE: CWR.L ) - Horsham, Sussex, United Kingdom - Developing fuel cell technology for use in small scale combined heat and power products for the residential sector and in energy security applications. Targeting global mass market opportunities in microgeneration for use in residential, commercial and leisure applications worldwide.
- Doosan Fuel Cell America - South Windsor, CT - (formerly ClearEdge Power, Inc.) - A fuel cell manufacturer focusing on the stationary fuel cell. The company employed 225 people as of August 2011. It closed its operations in Connecticut in April 2014, and filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May 2014. The company has been merged with Fuel Cell Power under a new name Doosan Fuel Cell .
CleanEdge Power sold a 5-kilowatt fuel cell for $56,000, or more than $10,000 a kilowatt. ClearEdge's stationary fuel cell takes natural gas and runs it through a membrane to produce hydrogen, heat, water and carbon dioxide. The hydrogen then passes through a second membrane to produce electrons before delivering electric power and heat to the building.
In August 2011, ClearEdge Power announced that it has raised a series E round of funding of $73.5 million, from a combination of new share sales and the conversion of previously issued notes. This round brings the company’s funding to about $100 million. Investors in ClearEdge’s latest round include Artis Capital Management, Güssing Renewable Energy, Sempra Energy’s Southern California Gas Company and Kohlberg Ventures.
In December 2012, ClearEdge reached an agreement with United Technologies Corp. to buy its fuel cell business, UTC Power. In February 2013, ClearEdge closed on its acquisition of UTC Power. The next month, the company reduced its workforce by 39%, with many layoffs coming at the former UTC unit. Later that month the company announced it had raised another $36 million in capital.
- Doty Energy - Columbia, SC - Plans to use off-peak wind energy to efficiently synthesize fuels, like gasoline and diesel, from CO2 and water. According to the company founder, David Doty, strong arguments for the concept include:
- the energy storage density in stable liquid fuels is two orders of magnitude greater than the energy storage density in batteries,
- the energy stored in liquid fuels can then be used seamlessly within our current transportation infrastructure, and
- the chemical processes being developed promise the scalability needed to competitively replace petroleum-based fuels. Doty's process electrolyzes water and combines the generated hydrogen with CO in a Fischer-Tropsch process to produce the liquid fuels.
- FuelCell Energy (NASDAQ: FCEL) - Danbury, CT - Develops and operates cell fuel power plants, Direct FuelCell power plants, to electrochemically produce electricity and heat from a range of basic fuel materials including natural gas and coal, etc. As the biggest publicly traded fuel cell manufacturer in the U.S., the company owns about 50 plants all over the world. Besides, it owns and operates the world’s largest fuel cell park, Gyeonggi Green Energy Fuel cell park, which is located in South Korea. The park consists of 21 power plants with 14.9 Megawatts.
- Hydrogenics (NASDAQ: HYGS) Mississauga, Ontario (US - Valencia, CA)- Has over 60 years of experience designing, manufacturing, building and installing industrial and commercial hydrogen systems around the globe Major manufacturers of PAFC technology.
- Neah Power,(OTCBB:NPWZ)) Bothell, Washington - Neah's product is a Direct Methanol Fuel Cell, but instead of using a PEM (proton exchange membrane), Neah uses porous silicon with a metalized surface. The porous silicon allows for a forty-fold increase in surface area and a potentially significant increase in power density. Three products thus far:
- The BuzzBar allows users to charge their mobile devices using virtually any source of energy that can plug into the BuzzBar including; wall outlets, batteries (BuzzBat™), solar power (BuzzSolTM), and the liquid fueled BuzzCell.™. During power outages or in third world countries with unreliable power grids, traditional mobile charging units that must be charged via a wall outlet quickly become useless. The BuzzBar family of products fills this critical gap in the market.
- The BuzzCell is a fuel cell technology that has no moving parts, under development at Neah for the last two years. The replaceable power cartridge consists of a bio-fuel and supporting electrolyte. Each cartridge is designed to hold one or more Smart Phone charges.
- PowerChip products are primarily available to military, government and corporate clients based on their specifications and integrated into their applications.
- The low-temperature GenSys fuel cell system provides remote, off-grid, and primary power where grid power is unreliable or non-existent.
- The high-temperature GenSys fuel cell system operates parallel to the grid as a replacement for traditional furnaces and boilers in residential and light commercial applications. The combined heat and power (CHP) system runs on natural gas at a temperature between 160° C and 180° C, making it compatible with existing home heating systems – working seamlessly with radiant, forced air or baseboard hot water.
- 2010 Fuel Cell Technologies Market Report , produced by the Breakthrough Technologies Institute, provides an overview of trends in the fuel cell industry, including product shipments, market development, and corporate performance. The report indicates continued growth in commercial deployments, especially material handling equipment like forklifts and lift trucks, combined heat and power (CHP), and back‐up and auxiliary power unit (APU) applications. The report shows that fuel cell costs continue to fall, noting that the high-volume cost of automotive fuel cells declined to $51 per kilowatt, an 80% reduction since 2002. Commercial sales continue to grow as the number of fuel cell units shipped from North America quadrupled between 2008 and 2010. With increasing market penetration, falling costs, and significant improvements in performance and durability, positive trends in the fuel cells market are expected to continue into 2011 and beyond. Released by DOE July 2011
- DOE - Hydrogen, Fuel Cells and Infrastructure Technology
- California Energy Commission – Fuel Cells
- NFRC - National Fuel Cell Research Center at The University of California at Irvine is the location of the . The mission of the NFCRC is to promote and support the fuel cell industry by providing the research, development and demonstration of fuel cell technologies. NFCRC's goal is to become a focal point for advancing fuel cell technology by creating partnerships with industry and state and federal agencies, including the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and the California Energy Commission.
- Fuel Cells 2000 Washington, DC - Their mission is to promote the commercialization of fuel cells and hydrogen by supplying accurate, unbiased industry information and developing and disseminating summary materials accessible to a general audience. Their materials and information are available free of charge. Fuel Cells 2000 is independent, non-aligned, and supports fuel cells of all types for all applications.